Showing posts with label Robert Kraft. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Kraft. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Updates: Trigger Warnings, Wally World, Sheeran et al., Smith and the Hawkeyes

 

Latest-Updates – Georgians for a Healthy Future

Curmie didn’t expect to be doing another “follow-up” post quite this soon, but there are a couple of new developments of late.  He’ll return to new topics soon, but not yet…

Trigger Warnings.  We’re going to take these updates in the order of Curmie’s original post on the subject.  We start, then, with this piece, written in May of 2024.  Curmie described the reactions of three of the world’s foremost actors—Sir Ian McKellen, Ralph Fiennes, and Dame Judi Dench—all of whom disparaged “trigger warnings” in live theatre events.  McKellen called many of them “ludicrous.”

Curmie managed to miss the news that the University of the West of England issued 220 warnings about Shakespearean plays, including, according to the New York Post, things like “storms, extreme weather and ‘popping of balloons.’”  But now there’s another furor surrounding a Royal Shakespeare Company “content advisory” for First Encounters: Julius Caesar, an adaptation set in a women’s prison, starring Dame Harriet Walter as Brutus.  If nothing else, the Daily Mail’s headline, “Forget the Ides of March, just beware the 14 trigger warnings of Julius Caesar!” is pretty apt. 

Walter hasn’t commented, at least that Curmie has seen, but two other acclaimed Shakespearean actresses have.  Felicity Kendal calls the warnings “patronising” and “absurd”; Janet Suzman’s word is “mollycoddling.”  Quoth Dame Janet, “They should be shouting out to audiences to come and be shocked and surprised and intrigued and not creep in nervously.”

Curmie once again notes that there are legitimate reasons for certain warnings: prospective spectators with certain medical conditions, for example.  Thus, the production’s flashing lights, which could trigger an epileptic episode, and which are not inherent in the script, do mean that the company should err on the side of caution.  But “characters experiencing grief” in a version of a Shakespearean tragedy?  Say it ain’t so!  Yeah, “patronising” seems pretty accurate.

It’s unclear exactly how these warnings appear.  It’s fine with Curmie if you have to look up specific concerns on the website.  If, however, those warnings are in any way unavoidable, then the RSC is in fact doing more harm than good with their nannying.

Walmart Follies.  At the end of the post about the trip Curmie and Beloved Spouse took to Ireland in July, he wrote about the fact that his old laptop died somewhere in transit.  He mentioned the fact that although the Walmart website said they’d deliver the replacement the day we ordered it, we subsequently got an email that said it wouldn’t be delivered until the following week.  So, we cancelled the order… and they sent it anyway.

We got information about how to return it to the local store.  But when Beloved Spouse (whose Walmart account we used for the order) tried to do that, she encountered no fewer than three rude and unhelpful people supposedly in the “customer service” business who informed her that they couldn’t take the laptop back because it was bought through “Walmart Marketplace.”  Needless to say, there was nothing on the website to indicate that, or we wouldn’t have bothered with them, given that the Marketplace is, shall we say, not famous for either competence or integrity.  Supervisor Dude made a big deal out of being “generous” and offering a gift card.  Beloved Spouse demanded a refund of the money we’d spent on the credit card, since it was Walmart’s fault.  Nope, he couldn’t do that.  We’d have to contact Walmart.com.

With no other choice, she came home and spent an hour and a half “chatting” online with Walmart customer service.  They gave the same line about a third-party vendor, and said the earlier message to take the laptop to the store was in error (well, whose fault is that?), but they also said they’d do what needed to be done to get us our refund; we’d hear back in 24-48 hours.  Needless to say, we didn’t. 

So, Curmie called Discover.  “Jessica in Illinois” was very helpful, took down a lot of information, and told me that they’d put a temporary hold on those charges until they could investigate further.  We had 15 calendar days to provide any documentation we could.  We sent stuff in online within that timeframe, and the status changed to having been ruled in our favor, but, reasonably enough, allowing the merchant to respond with their side of the story.

We just put a rather substantial charge on that account and were about to add another, so it was worth checking to see if there was any resolution to the affair.  Under “disputes” is this (unedited) message: “This case was previously closed in your favor and an adjustment(s) were applied to your account. The time allowed for the merchant to request additional review of this decision has expired. As such, We consider this investigation to be complete.”  In other words, after trying to take the laptop back for a refund, we now get the refund without having to return the computer.  Not a bad deal, even taking into account all the bullshit we (especially Beloved Spouse) had to endure.

Three take-aways, in whatever order you choose: 1). Avoid anything that even might be Walmart Marketplace.  Hell, avoid Walmart altogether if you can.  2). Discover customer service is actually very good.  3). Fight the bastards if you have to.

The Kraft/Macklemore/Sheeran Debacle.  Curmie wrote about Robert Kraft’s de facto firing of Macklemore from the Ed Sheeran concerts scheduled for September 24 and 25 at Gillette Stadium, which Kraft owns.  All the other artists—warm-up bands and Sheeran’s backing group—quit in solidarity.  Sheeran subsequently did a show in Philadelphia alone, and was apparently going to do the same in Foxboro… and then the nor’easter hit, and both shows were cancelled.  There’s some ironic finality there.

The other follow-up is that country star Zach Bryan set the all-time attendance record for Gillette Stadium on October 3, attracting 73,538 fans for the second of his two performances at the venue.  More significantly for the purposes of this essay, however, is that he wore a “Free Palestine” t-shirt at both shows.  Other members of the band also wore pro-Palestinian garb.  Bryan’s shirt didn’t have the Palestinian flag; instead, there was a pine tree logo and the phrase “An Appeal to Heaven.” 

This links to John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government.  [Side note: Curmie went over 15 years without mentioning Locke’s name in a blog post; now it’s appeared twice (the other one is here) in three weeks.]  The motto refers to the right of people to overthrow an oppressive regime, and, complete with the pine tree logo, was used on flags by colonial sailors in the Revolutionary War.  More recently, there’s some linkage to Christian Nationalism.  It’s unclear, in other words, what message Bryan was attempting to impart.

Bryan’s politics are, he says, libertarian and non-partisan; he has little use for either major party.  We do know that he’s pro-LGBTQ+ rights and anti-ICE, making him a bit of an outlier as a country singer, but not as an everyday citizen.  Is he advocating for the Palestinian cause because he believes in it, or because he doesn’t want to be told he can’t?  Certainly, whatever else Bryan may be saying, it’s a direct poke in the eye to Robert Kraft.  A good article in The Jerusalem Post argues that this is a variation on the Streisand Effect, and concludes: “Most major musicians are not wearing ‘Free Palestine’ shirts. If pressed and feeling that they are being told not [to], however, it’s possible that more of them will be.”

Of course, Kraft let the second night happen, despite folks like Sean Spicer tweeting, “Here’s hoping there is no night 2,” and that second night audience was even bigger than the night before’s.  Exactly why Kraft didn’t intervene is unclear—did he think it was too late, or he feared an even more significant Streisand Effect, or he wasn’t going to shut down the headliner, or Bryan didn’t have any track record of anti-Semitism, or refunding eight figures worth of tickets would be no fun at all, or…?

It’s Not about the Hawkeyes.  Or, rather, it’s only coincidentally about the Hawkeyes.  There’s no question that Senator Eric Schmitt made an absolute fool of himself in a botched “gotcha” moment in which he tried to prove perjury against former Special Counsel Jack Smith.  Schmitt had a very flimsy case to begin with, and then proceeded to have the whole thing collapse on national television when he called Smith a “dirtbag” for denying that he was in Atlanta the day after Fani Wallis admitted to her affair with Nathan Wade, as if that somehow proved something nefarious.

But it turned out that the basketball game Smith attended that night wasn’t the Golden State Warriors at the Atlanta Hawks, but the Iowa Hawkeyes (featuring star Caitlin Clark) at the Maryland Terrapins in women’s hoops. 

Three follow-ups: First, Curmie would love to believe that Smith suspected what Schmitt was attempting, and his obvious befuddlement at the line of questioning was in fact feigned, thereby giving Schmitt a little more rope with which to hang himself.  He did attend an Iowa/Maryland game about that time, he thinks…  If that’s what happened, Curmie likes him more than ever.  Smith would never admit it, of course.

Second, the intervention of Senator Klobuchar was timely and effective.  Her suggestion that Schmitt was confusing the Hawks and the Hawkeyes was plausible, and confirming that game on that date did blow up the whole interrogation.  Thing is, though, it was the assumption that the only basketball game in a large arena that night was in Atlanta that caused Schmitt’s self-destruction.  Klobuchar’s analysis was reasonable; it was also wrong. 

As Curmie wrote on October 1, “The problem wasn’t the coincidence of “Hawks” and “Hawkeyes” playing at the same time.  It was, rather, the casual sexism of being unable to understand that a grown man might want to watch a women’s game, even one that a). featured a player about to break the record for points in a collegiate career, and b). was within easy driving distance.”

The problem is that not only are the comedians and memesters making that mistake, but Klobuchar herself is taking something of a victory lap (“when you're from the Midwest, the Hawks also mean the Hawkeyes”) for something that turned out to be an irrelevant coincidence.  This was after we knew the real story.  That’s not cool, Senator.

Finally, Smith’s attendance at the Power to the People Festival last weekend has resulted in two sets of headlines.  Those of one political persuasion love the fact that Dave Grohl (in Maryland, in an Iowa Hawkeyes t-shirt) dedicated one of the Foo Fighters’ biggest hits, “My Hero,” to “my new friend Jack,” and got a few thousand fans to sing along.  Those of the other perspective are predictably exercised by the fact that Smith wore a “No Kings” t-shirt to the event, which also featured a set by Bruce Springsteen.  How dare someone who, after a thorough investigation, got multiple indictments against 45 only to have them dismissed by a Trump appointee exercise his 1st Amendment rights as a private citizen, after all?  <Sigh.>

There you go, Gentle Reader: four updates.  We’ll return to normal programming next time out.

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Why Is Curmie Thinking about Charles Frohman?

The guy in the photo is our title character, Charles Frohman (1856-1915).  We’ll get to him in a moment.

The chances are, Gentle Reader, that you already know as much or more about the reasons Ed Sheeran, Macklemore, and Robert Kraft appear in many of the same stories these days.  If you need a quick synopsis, here’s a reasonably inclusive story about the whole business. 

Well, not quite the whole business, as when Sheeran capitulated to Kraft (the owner of Gillette Stadium, where Sheeran is scheduled to perform this weekend) and dropped Macklemore from his Loop tour for the apparently unforgiveable crime of saying “Free Palestine,” all the other supporting and warm-up act musicians for upcoming gigs—Grammy-winning singer/songwriter Finneas, Irish singer Aaron Rowe, the Irish band Beoga (Sheeran’s backing band), and the Danish pop group Lukas Graham—quit in solidarity.  A lengthier and more recent play-by-play of the last couple of weeks is here.

Sheeran has been ridiculed for cowardice; SNL UK was particularly brutal.  He has argued all along that dropping Macklemore from the tour was not his call, but was made by promoters.  That’s true, but of course there’s more to the story than that. 

In his first concert since the… erm… fecal matters interfaced the whirling rotors, Sheeran engaged in a little self-pity and even cried onstage, but also delivered an apology, noting that “What happened in Israel and at the Nova Music Festival on Oct. 7 was horrific and compounded centuries of Jewish pain. What is happening in Gaza is catastrophic and unjustifiable and disproportionate.”  Even that came under immediate scrutiny, however: one critic described it as “pro-Israel, teleprompter-read propaganda” that could have been written by Kraft himself; another called it “everything you'd expect from a person in his position: equivocating, meaningless bullshit that was most likely written by someone else.”  Ouch.

OK, Sheeran is in a tough place.  Curmie actually buys his story that he didn’t want to disappoint his fans.  And his self-consciously apolitical approach is understandable, at least up to a point.  Creating a space where everyone, irrespective of their political views, can come together to enjoy the music is indeed a worthy goal.  But there comes a point at which that stance won’t work anymore. 

And it’s certainly not true that music, or indeed any art form, is or ought to be apolitical.  Such an argument would certainly raise an eyebrow from the likes of Woody Guthrie, Pete Seeger, or Bob Dylan… or, hell, from Francis Scott Key, for that matter.  But whereas most of the criticism of Sheeran has come from those whose perspective on events in Gaza mirror Macklemore’s, that isn’t Curmie’s argument.  What matters isn’t whether we agree on the content of his speech; it’s whether he has the right to say it. 

Significantly, this isn’t a Colin Kaepernick case whether the protest has nothing to do with the job; Macklemore’s political stance, agree with it or not, is part of the performance.  If you go to a concert featuring Jason Aldean, you’re gonna hear some right-wing rhetoric.  If it’s today’s birthday boy, Bruce Springsteen: it’ll come from the left.  Both are fine with Curmie, although he obviously prefers one to the other.

Sheeran, if he had a spine, would have looked Kraft square in the eye and said something like, “Macklemore is my friend, and he’s part of the company on this tour.  If he goes, I do, too.  I’ll apologize to my fans and refund their money, but this isn’t about who’s right and who’s wrong in a situation 5500 miles or so to the east,  It’s about something far more significant than a political disagreement; it’s about free speech.”

Maybe Kraft would back down, as authorities in Jacksonville, Florida did in 1964 when the Beatles refused to play to a segregated audience.  Maybe he wouldn’t, echoing South African officials when Dusty Springfield took the same stance that same year.  Even if Kraft were to remain intransigent, however, one suspects that Sheeran, whose net worth is about $400 million, could still afford to super-size his Big Mac combo even without getting more income from this tour.  Either way, he’d have stood up for the cause of free speech.

We might wish that Sheeran were made of sterner stuff, but he’s not really the villain here.  It’s a lot easier to blame someone else for a lack of courage than to exercise that courage oneself.  The real culprit would be Robert Kraft, who is the very caricature of a corporate multi-billionaire: he’s been smug, acquisitive, and hubristic for decades. 

Don’t get Curmie wrong on this: Kraft, like everyone else, is entitled to his opinion on international events, and to speak his truth as he sees it.  If he chooses not to accept Macklemore’s apology for an incident a dozen years ago in which the rapper appeared on stage in what could reasonably be described as a caricature of Jewishness, so be it.  He can even choose to conflate criticism of the Israeli government with antisemitism, although Curmie thinks that’s idiotic.  What Kraft cannot legitimately do is to prevent the speech of someone who disagrees with him, and he sure as hell doesn’t have the right (ethically, at least) to round up a posse of his fellow fat-cats to join in the boycott.

And now <drumroll> we’re ready to talk about Charles Frohman, a theatre manager and promoter at the turn of the 20th century.  Frohman was the driving force behind an organization which pretty much dominated the American theatre scene for about 20 years.  It was called The Syndicate.  If, Gentle Reader, that sounds like the name of some manifestation of organized crime, well, it pretty much was… except that it was legal.  And ol’ Charlie sure does look the part, doesn’t he?  All those gangster movies we’ve watched for years wouldn’t lead us astray, would they?

What Frohman and his buds did was to establish a virtual monopoly.  They managed both theatre productions and performance spaces.  In an era in which New York was not yet the epicenter of American theatre activity, national tours were more important and ubiquitous than they are today.  The Syndicate didn’t concentrate on big cities, but rather on the various smaller venues in between on the railroad lines.  Companies needed those one- or two-night stops to make the tour profitable, so there would be performances in towns of only if few thousand people.  If there was an opera house there, that was enough.

The Syndicate’s deal was that productions managed by the Syndicate could play only in Syndicate-run spaces, and those spaces could book only Syndicate-backed productions.  At the height of their influence, the Syndicate controlled about 1500 venues and productions featuring most of the biggest stars of the age—William Gillette, John Drew, Maude Adams, et al. 

If you control all the venues, you can control the performers, and vice versa.  That’s the lesson of the Syndicate.  And that’s a variation on what Robert Kraft is attempting to do by enlisting all his billionaire buddies to help him suppress any performer who is unwilling to play his game by his rules. 

There are differences, of course.  Kraft isn’t looking at small towns the way the Syndicate did.  He’s concentrating on huge venues, both because those are the ones over which he and his fellow billionaires can exercise control, and because the likes of Ed Sheeran, who can fill them, knows you can sell a lot more tickets to a lot more fans and make a lot more money for an event in an NFL stadium that seats 60 or 70 thousand than in even a huge auditorium that seats a third that many folks. 

The other difference is that Frohman and his cohorts were interested primarily in making money.  Kraft seeks, rather, to control the narrative: who can speak, and what they can say. 

And that, Gentle Reader, is much worse than just wanting to be rich(er).